COFFEE COOP
Apple Butter Making Process
Our apple butter begins with hand-selected apples that are slow-cooked for hours with warm spices until they achieve the perfect, spreadable consistency. Each batch is carefully crafted using traditional methods that bring out the natural sweetness of the ingredients.
- Fresh apples peeled, cored, and chopped for cooking
- Slow-simmered with cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves for depth
- Cooked down until thick, smooth, and perfectly spiced
- Small-batch process ensures consistent quality and flavor
Ingredients
Our small-batch apple butter delivers rich, concentrated apple flavor with warming spices. The smooth, spreadable texture makes it perfect for toast, biscuits, or cooking. Each jar captures the essence of fresh autumn apples in every spoonful.
Fresh Apples
We use locally-sourced apples, selecting varieties that provide the perfect balance of sweetness and tartness.
Pure Cane Sugar
Just enough organic cane sugar to enhance the natural apple sweetness without overpowering.
Warm Spices
Traditional blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves creates that classic apple butter taste.
Natural Apple Cider Vinegar
A touch of apple cider vinegar brightens the flavor and helps preserve freshness.
100% Gluten-Free
Safe for gluten-sensitive and celiac customers.
All-Natural Ingredients
No preservatives, no artificial flavors
No High Fructose Corn Syrup
We never use rBST or growth hormones in our milk.
Vegan-Friendly
Plant-based recipe perfect for all dietary preferences
Product Details
- Deep amber brown
- Smooth, spreadable consistency
- Rich apple flavor with warm spice notes
- Traditional homestyle apple butter
Recipe Ideas & Serving Suggestions
- Perfect spread for toast, biscuits, and muffins
- Stir into oatmeal or yogurt for instant flavor
- Essential ingredient for cookies and quick breads
Apple Butter Tradition
Apple butter has been a beloved American tradition since colonial times. Originally made in large copper kettles over open fires, this concentrated apple spread was a method for preserving the harvest.
Buy Now4.7 / 5.0
with over 2k+ reviews
Customers Love Our Apple Butter
Amy M
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“I’ve completely swapped out store-bought cheese for September Farm’s line. Their aged cheddars provide bold flavor without being overwhelming, and their cheese spreads are a staple in our household now. For energy throughout the day, I love pairing the Gouda with nuts or fruit—it keeps me going. And their gift boxes? So thoughtfully curated. I gave one to my boss, and she was over the moon! It’s the kind of quality you can taste and trust.”
Ashly A
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
"Love the branding and quality. September Farm’s cheese tastes amazing—natural, fresh, and never too salty. Big fan of the jalapeño cheddar!"
Jack J
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“I love the aged cheddar from September Farm. I’m not usually a cheese person, but this made me a believer. It’s bold and complex but not overpowering. You can taste the care in every batch!”
Davy G
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“I’m obsessed… I’ve only tried their aged and smoked cheeses so far, but I’m hooked! The texture and flavor are next level. I especially enjoy the horseradish cheddar when I want a kick, and their sweet cheese spreads are perfect for winding down at night with crackers. It’s so nice to have a cheese brand that’s both premium and personal. New favorite unlocked.”
Chad N
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“September Farm’s Smoked Cheddar is my favorite! For anyone trying to eat more whole, local foods without sacrificing flavor, this cheese is a perfect match. One bite and I was hooked—smoky, creamy, and absolutely satisfying. I always keep some stocked in the fridge.”
Corryn S
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“Love the logo and packaging! September Farm's cheese is top-notch—fresh, flavorful, and handcrafted. I picked some up at the roadside shop and now I’m hooked. Real quality and local charm in every bite.”
Amy M
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“I’ve completely swapped out store-bought cheese for September Farm’s line. Their aged cheddars provide bold flavor without being overwhelming, and their cheese spreads are a staple in our household now. For energy throughout the day, I love pairing the Gouda with nuts or fruit—it keeps me going. And their gift boxes? So thoughtfully curated. I gave one to my boss, and she was over the moon! It’s the kind of quality you can taste and trust.”
Ashly A
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
"Love the branding and quality. September Farm’s cheese tastes amazing—natural, fresh, and never too salty. Big fan of the jalapeño cheddar!"
Jack J
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“I love the aged cheddar from September Farm. I’m not usually a cheese person, but this made me a believer. It’s bold and complex but not overpowering. You can taste the care in every batch!”
Davy G
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“I’m obsessed… I’ve only tried their aged and smoked cheeses so far, but I’m hooked! The texture and flavor are next level. I especially enjoy the horseradish cheddar when I want a kick, and their sweet cheese spreads are perfect for winding down at night with crackers. It’s so nice to have a cheese brand that’s both premium and personal. New favorite unlocked.”
Chad N
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“September Farm’s Smoked Cheddar is my favorite! For anyone trying to eat more whole, local foods without sacrificing flavor, this cheese is a perfect match. One bite and I was hooked—smoky, creamy, and absolutely satisfying. I always keep some stocked in the fridge.”
Corryn S
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“Love the logo and packaging! September Farm's cheese is top-notch—fresh, flavorful, and handcrafted. I picked some up at the roadside shop and now I’m hooked. Real quality and local charm in every bite.”
Jasmine P
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“The cheese is amazing. I like how flavorful it is without being overly salty, and it melts beautifully. The Monterey Jack is smooth and perfect for sandwiches.”
Chelsea S
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“Delicious and unique! I brought a cheese sampler from September Farm to a family event and everyone loved it. The flavor combos are unexpected and fun—plus, it's great supporting a family business rooted in local values.”
Cindy H
Verified Buyer
Would Recommend
“I love that September Farm is family-owned and committed to crafting authentic, small-batch cheeses using traditional methods. Their aged cheddar is unlike anything I've had—rich, sharp, and creamy all at once. It’s not just about taste; it’s the comfort and warmth that comes with each bite. I keep their smoked Gouda in stock for relaxing evenings, and it pairs beautifully with wine or crackers.
Taste the Quality of Our Apple Butter
We craft artisan apple butter that truly delivers on taste and quality...
You may also like
View all
